INDEPENDENT RECIPE CHECK

WHICH DOG FOODS ACTUALLY CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT?

I checked 17 of them, so you don’t have to.
Buckwheat-free fresh, gently cooked and shelf-stable options, based on current recipes and brand confirmations.
Checked 19 August 2026. Recipes can change, so always check the current ingredient declaration.
I CHECKED 17 OF THEM.   SO YOU DON’T HAVE TO.

Avoiding buckwheat after the Years recall?

Following on from my previous post about the Years recall and buckwheat, I’ve put together a second list of fresh, gently cooked and shelf-stable foods for anyone who would prefer to avoid buckwheat altogether.

For anyone who doesn’t know me, I’m Emma Rutherford, a pet food formulator and recipe developer with over 20 years’ experience in fresh food. I spend a lot of time looking forensically at formulations, ingredients and how foods are put together, so I wanted this list to be as clear and useful as possible.
I’ve separated foods where the brand has specifically confirmed they do not contain buckwheat from those where I’ve checked the current published recipes and ingredient lists.

Important: Fidelis has a Pork with Buckwheat, Pumpkin & Blueberries recipe, so check the individual recipe.
Nothing has been confirmed to date about the cause of the issues associated with the Years recall, and this guide is not suggesting that buckwheat has been proven to be responsible. It simply gives owners who would prefer to avoid it for now an easy place to start.

BUCKWHEAT FREE

Fresh cooked, gently cooked & shelf-stable options

BRAND
BUCKWHEAT IN RECIPES?
BRAND STATEMENT / VERIFICATION
Different Dog
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
Brand statement: manufacturer confirmed
barkinBISTRO Cooked
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
No buckwheat listed in published ingredients checked
Pets Love Fresh Fresh Frozen
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
No buckwheat listed in published ingredients checked
Butternut Box
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
Brand statement: manufacturer confirmed
Nutriment Fresh Medallions
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
Brand statement: manufacturer confirmed
Paws on Plates
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
Brand statement: manufacturer confirmed
DIBO Fresh Menu
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
No buckwheat listed in published ingredients checked
Boost Fresh
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
No buckwheat listed in published ingredients checked
Freshpet UK
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
No buckwheat listed in published ingredients checked
Fidelis
⚠ ONE RECIPE CONTAINS BUCKWHEAT
Contains buckwheat in: Pork with Buckwheat, Pumpkin & Blueberries
Nutriment Gently Steamed
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
Brand statement: manufacturer confirmed
Marleybones Pantry Fresh
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
Brand statement: manufacturer confirmed
Natures Menu Wet
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
No buckwheat listed in published ingredients checked
Wilsons Fresh
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
No buckwheat listed in published ingredients checked
Forthglade Wet
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
No buckwheat listed in published ingredients checked
Naturediet Complete Meals
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
No buckwheat listed in published ingredients checked
Phoenix Bark (Small Batch)
✓ DOES NOT CONTAIN BUCKWHEAT
No buckwheat listed in published ingredients checked

INDEPENDENT RECIPE CHECK

STOPPED FEEDING YEARS? WHAT DO YOU FEED NOW?

I checked 17 of them, so you don’t have to.
Fresh • gently cooked • chilled • shelf-stable • complete wet. Compared using the same formulation criteria.
Recipes checked 20 August 2026. Formulations can change.

Years recall: what can I feed instead?

Following the voluntary Years recall, many owners are looking for cooked alternatives. Years has advised customers to STOP FEEDING its fresh meals immediately. I’ve looked at the published formulations of some of the main UK options. Recipes can vary within a brand.

Quick guide

LOW – lower according to my formulation criteria    MODERATE – moderate    HIGH – higher    NOT STATED – published information was not clear enough to classify.
These ratings reflect my professional formulation criteria and opinion, based on the published recipes and information available.

Closest to my whole-food approach

PHOENIX BARK

A clear stand-out.

More of the nutritional work is being done by the food itself rather than relying on a broad vitamin/mineral pack.

D3 + E only
Whole-food-led
Moderate starch

Well done, Phoenix Bark.

FRESH / FROZEN GENTLY COOKED OPTIONS

BRAND
ADDED NUTRIENTS
SOURCE / FORM
STARCH / PULSES
BarkinBistro
E, zinc, manganese, copper + iodine
Mainly inorganic mineral salts
Moderate
Different Dog
A, D3, E, zinc, iron, manganese + iodine
Not clearly stated
Moderate
Pets Love Fresh
Vitamin + mineral blend
Mixed chelated + inorganic minerals
Low
Butternut Box
Broad vitamin/mineral supplementation, varying by recipe
Many minerals are chelated; some recipes also use organic selenium
Moderate
Nutriment Fresh Medallions
A, D3, E, iron, iodine, copper, manganese, zinc + selenium
Not clearly stated
Low
Paws on Plates
A, E, zinc, iron, manganese, copper, iodine + calcium carbonate
Mainly inorganic mineral salts
Moderate
Monty’s Larder
Vitamins + multiple minerals
Not clearly stated
Moderate
DIBO Fresh Menu
A, D3, E, iron, iodine, copper, manganese, zinc + selenium
Not clearly stated
Moderate
Boost Fresh
D3, E, zinc, manganese, copper + iodine
Mainly inorganic mineral salts
Moderate

OTHER COOKED ALTERNATIVES CHECKED

BRAND
ADDED NUTRIENTS
SOURCE / FORM
STARCH / PULSES
Freshpet UK
Broad vitamin/mineral additions
Varies / not clearly stated
Moderate
Wilsons Fresh
Broad vitamin/mineral additions
Not clearly stated
Generally higher
Fidelis
D, zinc, copper, manganese + selenium
No artificial vitamins stated; mineral forms not fully stated
Moderate
Nutriment Gently Steamed
A, D3, E, zinc, iron, copper, manganese, iodine + selenium
Not clearly stated
Low
Marleybones Pantry Fresh
A, D3, iron, copper, manganese + zinc
Mainly inorganic mineral salts
Moderate
Natures Menu
D3, E + multiple minerals
Mainly inorganic mineral salts
Moderate
Forthglade Wet
A, D3, E, zinc, iron, copper + iodine
Key minerals are chelated
Moderate
Naturediet
A, D3 + multiple minerals
Mainly inorganic mineral salts
Varies by recipe

Important recipe notes

Fidelis: One recipe contains buckwheat: Pork with Buckwheat, Pumpkin & Blueberries.

Wilsons Fresh: Also uses eggshell as a calcium source.

My formulation view

CALCIUM MATTERS

I’m not a fan of calcium carbonate or eggshell as the primary calcium source.

In adult dogs, bioavailability concerns me. In puppies, the calcium:phosphorus balance is critical.

MY BENCHMARK

Minimal added nutrients.
Low starch.
Full transparency.
Full predicted nutritional analysis.

I haven’t found a UK cooked food that ticks every box yet.

I have formulated complete cooked pet foods commercially without added vitamins, so I know it can be done.
For context, I’m a recipe developer and commercial pet food formulator, not a pet nutritionist. They are different roles.